Menyhart Plumbing & Heating Supply

Menyhart Plumbing Supply is a retail supply shop, not a contracting service, so Project Completion (job delivery, callbacks, on-site work) is not applicable and returns no data. Professionalism scores well overall — the vast majority of reviewers praise helpful, patient, and friendly staff — but is meaningfully pulled down by one review citing a complete failure to return calls and a second se... Read more

Menyhart Plumbing Supply is a retail supply shop, not a contracting service, so Project Completion (job delivery, callbacks, on-site work) is not applicable and returns no data. Professionalism scores well overall — the vast majority of reviewers praise helpful, patient, and friendly staff — but is meaningfully pulled down by one review citing a complete failure to return calls and a second serious review describing a customer being called an idiot and refused a warranty exchange on a defective and dangerous part. Pricing scores positively, with multiple reviewers highlighting that parts cost a fraction of big-box or plumber-quoted prices, though one reviewer paid 75% more than online pricing for a defective re-boxed part, tempering the score. Experience is the strongest dimension, with nearly every reviewer explicitly praising the staff's deep technical knowledge, vast inventory of obscure and antique parts, and accurate problem-solving advice on the first visit. The WW Score reflects a genuinely strong local specialty supplier with a long track record, modestly penalized for documented service failures. Read less