Review and analyze now for company Gotelli Plumbing Company and provide the analysis in the discussed format for the following reviews: '''WOW! I can't say enough about Laura-Lee and the staff at Gotelli Plumbing. I called with an urgent matter and they were so wonderful to jump to the task.
They never fail to accomplish the most difficult jobs we send their way. On this occasion, our technician Jason arrived ahead of schedule, had all of the parts and items on his truck ready to go and made quick work of an install.
Not only did he complete the job to perfection, he left the area surrounding the new water heater cleaner than he found it. We will always make our first call Gotelli Plumbing.
When you're calling a plumber, the likelihood is that you're probably facing something that is beyond your means to repair, potentially even an emergency. I'm happy to report that I received excellent service from start to finish with Gotelli.
Long story short, I had a tankless hot water heater that was on its last legs and even caused a leak in my ceiling over the Christmas holiday due to a failed recirculating pump in my attic. I called Gotelli the next day and they sent out a technician right away who showed up 45 minutes later and we we walked through the problems I was facing and the potential solutions.
The weather was dreadful, pouring buckets, yet they still took their time to answer all of my questions to make sure I had as much information to make my decision as I could. It took me a few days to compare prices and availability, and since this happened between Christmas and New Year's, scheduling was top of mind.
While figuring out what to do. I received a follow up from Gotelli asking if there was anything else I needed to decide on how to proceed.
I found this to be very helpful as there were a few questions that I had, which were easily answered and we quickly figured out the next steps and scheduled the installation for the following Tuesday after the holiday. This was on a Friday before the long New Years weekend, and I have to say I was impressed with their ability to squeeze me in.
I was lucky enough to work with Jason Ralph and his apprentice, and they did a phenomenal job with the install making sure that all the details were taken care of. They even saved me money as it was determined we did not need an extra recirculating pump for the kitchen sink which was a welcome surprise.
The installation looks amazing and I'm super happy with my choice of Plumber. They even added an expansion tank to my system which has helped with the knocking in my pipes, which was an unexpected benefit.
It just goes to show you that working with a professional pays off in many ways, some of which you don't even realize at the time. I've read many reviews on this company, and it does seem to be a little hit or miss, depending on what your experience was.
In my case, all I have to say is that I would do it again in a heartbeat, and I was pleased with the service, the value, and the expertise provided by Gotelli. My hot water is divine and I no longer have to wait minutes for the water to get warm.
Life changer and sure to save on my water and propane bills in the future. I'm writing this review to warn others about the poor experience we had with Gotelli.
Not only are their prices exorbitant, but their expertise is not to par. We initially hired them for a simple toilet repair, which they quoted at an outrageous price compared to other plumbers.
Desperate, we reluctantly agreed, hoping their supposed expertise would justify the cost. We were wrong.
First of all, I don't understand why looking into the tank and diagnosing the pump as an issue wouldn't also identify immediately that the rubber below the flap was falling apart. There are only 3 parts there.
A trained eye would have noticed that before even starting. Isn't that the idea behind the $120 consult to figure out what's wrong? To inspect all parts? Each fix led to another issue resulting in us needing a new toilet.
The quote for a new toilet installation was $1200 (NOT including the actual toilet). Yup, you read that correctly.
This is for 1-1.5 hours worth of work. We relied on Gotelli's expertise to find a similar fit.
The new toilet left us with a new issue to replace the floor because the new toilet has a smaller base something they should have known or made sure of. We ended up paying a small fortune for multiple visits, each one leaving us with a new issue.
Gotelli prioritizes profit over customer satisfaction. They overcharge for basic services and then compound the issue leaving you with a $1800 bill, and a mismatched toilet.
My recommendation is to look elsewhere. Came in at a short notice to replace a leaking pipe.
The work was done well, efficiently and is of good quality. The prices are a bit on the expensive side but nevertheless we are satisfied with the services provided.
Gotelli plumbing was able to get two plumbers to me on the same day of my call. Jason and Adam were the two plumbers that arrived.
They were professional, efficient and fair. I highly recommend Jason and/or Adam to anyone looking for a trust-worthy hard-working plumber.
Jason did a great job on the disassembly of a water tank connected to a solar system. Somewhat complicated configuration while he worked through the process with logical steps and a welcome solution.
He is a highly skilled pro, efficient, and has great workmanship. Courteous, friendly and offered several suggestions that will serve me well.
Tom Robertson of Gotelli provided excellent, responsive , and reliable service. Tom was able to explain our plumbing problem and recommend clear and specific solutions.
I would definitely recommend him and the company as well. They're probably fine....but I wasn't going to pay close to a hundred bucks just for a water heater estimate.
Other companies didn't have that policy and they got my business...? My usual plumber was unavailable so I decided to try Gotelli. I had a drip leak of my outside home water line.
It appeared to be a worn out washer or seal of some sort. The employee came, looked at it for a minute or so and typed into his iPad.
He told me the project would cost around $1,600. When i asked for the breakdown of the pricing he said they done give that out .
He also offered a "free" inspection of my water heater...he said I had a leak there too and that would be an $8,000 project. Serious upsell and not trustworthy.
I paid him the service fee and had Burkell Plumbing come out at the recommendation of a neighbor. A washer fixed my leak and I was only charged $75.
They charged us a price of $475 to snake one outdoor drain that wasn't even able to be cleared. It took them a total of one hour from start to finish.
Do not recommend. They tell you that they have an $89 fee to come out and assess that is waived once the job is started.
They don't tell you how expensive it is upfront to snake one outdoor drain. We would have found a more reasonable and fair company like Roto-Rooter that at least gives you its fees upfront.
I have had two experiences with Gotelli plumbing. In 2019, when I was out of town, my wife needed to call a plumber for an emergency.
She called Gotelli. The plumber who came to our house, Jeff, gave her an estimate for the work and then grossly overcharged her when the job was done.
She felt cornered and had no choice but to pay the bill. When I got home and learned of the situation, I wrote a long and highly critical letter to Gotelli concerning this treatment.
However, last week, we needed to replace several of the aging pipes and connections underneath our 60-year-old house. I received bids from 3 highly-rated plumbers and decided to give Gotelli another chance.
Tremendous decision. I was especially impressed with Joey who came out to survey the job and provide me a fair quote.
It was not the lowest quote, but I felt good about him. A week later, Joey and Sebastian showed up at our home and fixed the main job and a few other smaller jobs.
We couldn't have been more pleased with the quality of their work, their professionalism, and their overall fun attitudes. I would strongly recommend Gotelli and also suggest that you ask for Joey.
Our family hired Gotelli Plumbing to help with plumbing issues inside of our family's house . Our mother who is elderly is always worried about people coming into her house and trying to take advantage of elderly people .
We had one of there workers named Jared Skaggs come to the house . He made our mother feel very comfortable and safe and quoted her a very fair price for the work.
If you are looking for any plumbing work, look no further. this is a very reputable company and they care about there results.
Called Gotelli first thing this morning for a plugged toilet. They had a man out within an hour or less "during the holidays".
Jared did an excellent job and I would highly recommend Gotelli Plumbing. This is the second job done for us on short notice and with some challenges.
I am very pleased and happy to highly recommend them. Just noticed that I accidentally hit the 4 instead of 5, my bad! Overall excellent experience with this shop!!! Same day kitchen disposal P-trap replacement service, promptly and politely executed by Donte.
Easy online scheduling. EDITED REVIEW: Changing one star to four as they have graciously agreed to fix the valve that became inoperable after their unclogging service.
Supervisor I spoke with was polite, explanatory and accommodating. One star still missing because it was not a stellar experience.
Needed our toilet unclogged. Tech couldn't snake it.
Had to take stool off the wall to fix. After putting the stool back and taking care of the clog, the water to the bowl no longer shuts off.
It keeps running after the flush fills the bowl. This wasn't an issue BEFORE the fix, so why should I have to pay nearly $600 (and that's the add on price! The stand alone rebuild price was around $800/$900 to my recollection) for them to fix something that was obviously caused by them servicing the stool!? I called the office to explain the situation, express my discontent and see if they could offer me a solution I would be happy with.
Nicole offered to let me speak to the tech who tried to charge me to fix something that wasn't broken before he worked on the clog and I said why would I want to speak with him? He's the one trying to charge me to fix something he caused to happen! I think I need a supervisor or manager. She says, and I kid you not, "Before you CUT ME OFF, I was going to offer you the supervisors voicemail too" with a tone of voice and attitude my teenage daughter has perfected.
Wow... Nearly my whole career is in customer service, and you know the number one thing you don't do to an upset customer? Antagonize them.
Her reply was way out of line, not at all conciliatory. I wasn't using profanity, I didn't raise my voice with her, I didn't insult her, I admit I was upset, indignant about the situation, and yes, I interrupted her telling me I could talk to the tech...But the clapback was very unprofessional.
Kind of like charging someone to fix something that was working fine before you "fixed" the thing it's on. I think anyone would agree if you call someone to unclog your toilet, and they do that, but you still can't use your toilet because he shut the water off due to it running all the time because of something that happened when he was fixing the clog, you'd be upset too Nicole.
That was crazy. I won't use them again.
I think a company should fix your issue, not cause one. And for a thousand dollar unclogging, I expect my valve to work as it did BEFORE you unclogged the toilet it was attached to.
This is the third time I have used Gotelli and once again the experience has been exceptional. I called in a panic that my tenant had called at 8:00 in the morning saying that they had no hot water.
I called Gotelli and Joey Bernsten was at their house within an hour. Joey was so easy to work with.
He explained what the problem was, what needed to be done, and of the time and cost and took it from there. Once Gotelli is on the job you know you can sit back knowing the job is in good hands.
Thank you Gotelli and Joey. You are the best! It's our second time using Gotelli.
We had a small clog issue in the bathroom sink last week and 2 technicians were able to come out the next day and fix it. It was a bit more complicated than expected, but they had the tools and the knowledge and fixed it cleanly.
I appreciate that one of the technicians kept booties over his shoes for the whole service, keeping my floors clean. These guys did the job in less than 20 minutes and they worked efficiently.
Would call them again. Steve Smith, serviced our call.
He completed as thorough inspection and advised me on the repairs and costs. I scheduled for the service that we discussed.
Steve was on time and put in a new faucet in our kitchen and then repaired two p-traps in our two restrooms. He completed all of the work in a very reasonable time and I was extremely happen with his work.
I highly recommend Gotelli Plumbing for a quick response and a completed job to my satisfaction. The staff interaction has been clear, concise and helpful.
Gotelli is the best. We woke up today to no hot water.
I called Gotelli and within an hour, Fernando arrived, investigated and resolved the hot water heater issue, plus did a review of the entire plumbing system. He is professional, personable, outlined the options, and got the job done.
Garbage disposal went out. I called Erwyns Plumbing Inc.
and he told me $400. I decided to call around though.
Dumb. I called Gotelli and they told me they would come out for $89 to diagnose and apply the $89 to the disposal replacement balance.
Big mistake. The $89 is not refundable if you change your mind.
They came out and said the garbage disposal DID need to be replaced but they wanted $669.08!!!!!! What I should have done was eat the $89 and called Erwyns Plumbing back. Gotelli guy replaced it in less than 20 min.
I GOT TAKEN FOR A RIDE! Oh well. Won't do that again.
Gotelli is overpriced! Any company that's worth anything won't charge you for diagnosing an issue. They only took 20 min! :( We used Gotelli Plumbing before, and our experience with their team has always been outstanding.
We had to do our annual backflow preventer testing. Nicole, who scheduled our appointment, was very friendly and joyful.
Sam is highly knowledgeable, courteous, and talented. I was surprised to learn that Sam had 18 years of experience as he looked in his late 20s.
If I could give Sam and Gotteli Plumbing 100 stars, I would. We will continue to use and recommend Gotteli Plumbing.
Came out to asses a leak which turned out to be a faulty bathroom faucet. We had a replacement faucet on hand.
I would agree that the vanity was small and it wouldn't be a super easy change out due to space issues. However the quote was at first $900+.
When I balked the price was lowered to $800+. I asked how long he expected it would take to change the faucet.
2.5-3 hours he said. Since when do plumbers make $300 and hour?? That rate is exorbitant.
Be careful when you have them come out. They don't charge by the hour but by the job.
Faucets change outs cost $900+ as their standard charge. If you don't have them do the work you are out $89 which they were clear about up front.
This review is way overdue. Tom with Gotelli is a miracle worker.
We decided to bite the bullet and call a plumber a couple of days before Christmas. We had one shower that was leaking and out of a commission for quite some time and another with a broken handle.
We put a request out to yelp and Tom contacted us almost immediately and said he could come out the next morning. He gave us a super fair quote and got started right away.
While working to repair both showers he discovered a water pressure issue that we didn't really know we had. Within no time we had two working showers and our water pressure was amazing!! Not only was he super knowledgeable and efficient he was just an all-around nice guy.
I cant recommend him enough. Thank you Tom and Gotelli Plumbing :) My last review was about an outrageous quote.
$6500 for a conventional water heater replacement. In that review, I said I remembered a good friend's brother was a plumber, we did it ourselves.
I had put this on another company's yelp review with similar quote but at $8k LOL. So either one of these companies reported me to the county about not having to pull a permit.
Well, the county told me that they hear this often, wonder why. I thought it was a scam to have to pull a permit, never heard of that for a simple water heater, we not building a pool.
But ok I pay for a permit $85, your quote was $400 to "pull a permit". It is a 10 minute online app, you don't have to wait in line at city hall and fill out by pen, this ain't 1990 anymore.
Why you charge $400 when its about $100? An inspector came and said everything was done perfectly, PASS. And it wasn't an all day job as you guys mentioned.
Also, PRV replacement for $900!!!??? The expansion tank needed to be replaced with water heater, that was throwing off the pressure. $60 tank at Lowe's that you guys quoted $400.
No need to replace PRV, online part is $200??? Got water heater at Lowe's most expensive one $1500. Lowe's offers installation and got quoted $1200 including a permit.
So $2700. I could of done that but rather give that money and help a friend's business.
I mean if you guys were around $4k I would of went for it, local business and I am sure you guys have the experience over Lowe's, years and years but come on, COVID times, everything is more expensive and lots of people are struggling. You need to make your margin, but not this crazy.
Great job always! Calvin a team are trustworthy and dependable. Looking forward to using them again We saw what we thought was a leak from a bathroom.
That was until a different bathroom shower wasn't draining well Then another shower was had and whoa! Huge sewer back up into our downstairs bathroom. AWFUL! We called Gottelli at 8:30 am and our man Jared was here by 9:30am It turned out our sewer line to the street was plugged.
He unclogged it as best as he could We need to contact the city now about replacing the connection. Tree roots are involved too Jared had been out before to install a circulation pump to the hot water heater.
No more wasting water while the water gets hot Anyhow Gottelli and Jared are awesome Did I mention that Jared is not only professional, knowledgeable but good looking too! I had Gotelli plumbing come out to inspect our crawlspace, under the townhouse, for a sump pump, as we have some water pooling there. The service was very professional and setting up the appointment was easy.
They told me that they charge $89 for coming out and I was fine with that. The technician who came out was very professional and courteous as well.
However, when I took him to the crawlspace, he said that they charge $385 to crawl under the Townhouse and inspect it! This was a shocker as I had specifically said that I wanted the crawlspace inspected when I setup the appointment. They should have told me this when I first setup the appointment.
Further the technician told me that they don't work with HOAs anyway! Wow, they could mention this on their website or even ask when they make an appointment! I ended up paying $89 for absolutely nothing. Gotelli needs to do a better job sharing this kind of information up front! They are so professional in other respects.
Joey arrived early and he installed the parts I had purchased. He offered me a senior discount which I very much appreciated.
Called them to fix a toilet that was running. The work seemed okay, but the repair guy was there less than a half hour and charged almost $400 ($393.66 to be exact).
When I asked them for a breakdown of parts and labor, they refused to give me one, and said that everything was by "the job" --- which leads me to wonder how it came down to EXACTLY 66 cents... (guess they are trying to make it seem like there was actually some "calculation" involved in determining the price).
I know everything is expensive these days, but this really seemed excessive and felt very ripped off. Would never call them again and do NOT recommend.
Overall a mixed experience. We had a leak under our sink which we could not diagnose.
We called this company to come fix it, and they scheduled us quickly and professionally. The plumber came and spent some time diagnosing the problem, and he recommended changing one old hose and the garbage disposal.
Total cost $900. We accepted the quote and he went ahead and made the changes.
He did it quickly and left the area clean and presentable. So far so good.
Unfortunately, this did not fix the leak at all, so our $900 and a perfectly good disposal were both wasted. I called the company angrily the following day and they sent out a plumber and a seemingly senior plumber, diagnosed the leak again and seemed to find it this time (in the hose in the faucet) and replaced it.
I have not seen the leak recur but I will obviously update this review if it does. Overall, we paid $900 for work that we did not need, but at least they did not try to charge us for the work they did to diagnose and fix the hose that actually was the problem.
I would have left this as a 4 or 5 star review if they had offered to refund the cost for the labor to install the hose and disposal that we didn't need that they did yesterday and only charge me for the parts (only fair since we are keeping the disposal) + the cost of the parts and labor needed to actually fix the problem. But at least the leak is gone.
And the new disposal is a bit quieter than the old one. My wife and I moved from the Central Valley to Petaluma two years ago, during the Pandemic.
Our "new" house is about 20 years old. We knew that we wanted new appliances but it's difficult to do everything at once on a fixed income.
So, long story short; we finally saved up and went out and bought all new kitchen appliances. We found a good price at a big box store near us.
The appliances were delivered and some installed, but the house was not set up to accommodate some of the hookups for the gas and/or water requirements. That which could be installed and hooked up, was installed and hooked up.
The workers indicated that I was going to need a plumber. I called Gotelli and they sent a man out the same day.
Tom Anderson arrived and assessed our situation. He also diagnosed a leak inside the garage wall and installed a new water heater! The problems with the appliances were fixed with an expertise and level of ability that is rare in this present day.
Along with that, Tom noticed that one of the new appliances had been installed incorrectly. Suffice it to say; Tom did everything right.
His affable, easy to like personality stands in the shadow of his "old school" work ethic, attention to detail and 100% dedication to customer satisfaction and quality service. We could not be more pleased and satisfied with the job and work performed by Tom Anderson beneath the umbrella of the Gotelli Plumbing Company.
In this world, you get what you pay for. Gotelli Plumbing is worth a little extra because of the quality and customer service provided.
I would not hesitate to call them again for any plumbing related needs. Tom of Gotelli Plumbing is a wizard.
He knows what to do as soon as he sees it and makes sure it's done right! Nicole in the office keeps everything going and is always sweet on the phone. Highly recommended! Wow, I failed to read the reviews about all the formerly satisfied customers that have turned irate over fee structure changes.
Wish I had. Now I'm out $817 for not paying attention.
We have used Gotelli before and were satisfied with both the quality of work and the price. Unfortunately, their billing model has changed.
It's now over the top outrageous. First, off, yes, they charge a $89 diagnostic fee and it doesn't go towards any work.
While that feels greedy, I can understand their point of view. We had them out because we had a list of small plumbing issues such as dripping faucets etc that needed attention.
They came out, spent an hour on the diagnostic and then went and wrote up a bid for the items that needed attention. After presenting me the bid and picking my jaw up off the floor, I agreed to have them do two small tasks; replace two outer hose bibs and change the washer responsible for a drip in the bathtub.
This work took an addition 45 minutes. The final bill for 1.75 hours of work was $817.
Outrageous. Not sure why they're willing to let all these loyal customers abandon them, but so be it.
PS - I should note that my wife and I don't like to slam small businesses on social media without giving them a chance to defend themselves. My wife called the office and shared our displeasure and she was met with total dismissal.
So they're free to cash our check and we're free to warn you to guard your wallet. Gotelli no longer breaks down labor and material costs, but quote a ridiculous 'task' fee for any job.
So they tried to charge me nearly $1,000 to replace a kitchen faucet and a couple of angle valves, using parts they had in the truck. Look elsewhere unless you like getting ripped off.
I have used them for many years for multiple tasks and always happy, but after today sadly it will be my last time. I had a simple job of unclogging a shower that took no longer than a half hour and paid $274.
Ridiculous. They now tack on a diagnostic fee of $80 that does NOT go towards the cost of fixing the task.
Called to price a tankless water heater and they wanted to charge $90 (actually $89) to give me an estimate which others do for free. That takes a lot of gall! Granted they would do a plumbing assessment which I do not want.
They wouldn't even an estimate or price of just the unit either! Well congrats you have succeeded in scaring me off, I am going somewhere else and suggest you do the same. Wow, I just had Tom here from Gotelli Plumbing and he was amazing.
I am always looking for that obsessed with doing it best and right person. This is that company and definitely this Guy! We were at first alarmed at the cost but quickly the way he was able to assess our layout other items of query, you knew he TOTALLY knew what he was talking about.
Quickly grading and assessing other people work and installment. This put us at ease immediately and realized okay, if this is the price to have this guy, we will do it cause in the long run he's planning and saving us from other problems that may lay just ahead or even in the long term.
His is a very interesting and personable guy. So glad I was referred this company and well now,Tom's our guy! He came to address a water running sound in one of our old toilets- needed a new seal.
And flush out our Noritz Wall hang Water Heater~ we know it should be flushed every year but we were a year behind and this pandemic is not helpful. He came in a mask and had booties if he came inside.
A well prepared guy. I highly recommend this company and Tom! I have used Gotelli Plumbing off and on for 15 years.
They no longer charge by the hour, instead they give you a fixed price on the spot for the work. If you refuse the estimate, you have to pay a fee and then find another plumber to come on another day.
They grossly overcharged me and refused to adjust the charge. I wound up paying $833 for 1.5 hours of a plumber's time.
About $600/hour. I suggest you find a plumber that charges fair rates.
Not Gotelli. We had purchased our home just six month ago.
Unfortunately, one of our under the sink pipes started leaking. Gotelli came out the day after I called them about the problem.
The plumber was professional and friendly. He investigated and found a cracked fitting and one lines washer/fitting was smashed inside.
He replaced the brass fitting and the water flex hose. All within a reasonable time span.
I highly recommend using their services. I have been a customer of Gotelli's for 25 years, but NO MORE.
In shock, pressed for time, and dealing with a difficult tenant, I agreed to pay $490 to replace a toilet flapper and a out door hose bib. It took the plumber 35 minutes to do this.
I asked the plumber what the hourly rare was and he responded that they no longer use an hourly rate. Future customers beware! I had a pretty bad experience and this company.
They were able to come out the same day, which was great. But that's where it went down hill.
The technician they sent quickly went to work on cleaning my sewer line, but neglected to ask me if i have a sewer ejector system. And because he didn't ask (and I didn't think to tell him), he winds up snaking my pump and severing the power line to it.
He then blames me for this mistake because i didn't tell him. The problem was far bigger than he could handle and he so wound up leaving after he fixed another toilet for me.
He winds up charging me $800 basically just for fixing a toilet and cleaning a line that didn't fix the problem. In his defense, the pump could have been broken before he further messed it up, but there are plenty of explanations that wouldn't require such a big expense.
He then tells me he'll replace the broken pump for $1900. For perspective on how absurd this price was, another company came over the following day and was able to clean out the sewage and replace the pump for $1600.
Huge fan of Gotelli Plumbing! We had Sam out this spring to install a new hose bib for an irrigation project. He was efficient, friendly and super competent--we have an old house with funky plumbing, and he was able to really think through the project and actually simplify our weird pipe situation.
We'd had another plumber out before who just added to the madness, whereas San really took the time to think about it and do the best possible fix, not just the easiest one. Fast forward to a few days ago and we had a different outdoor pipe spring a leak! Gotelli didn't have an appointment the next day, but they were able to put us on a waiting list in case there was a cancellation.
Amazingly, there was a cancellation and Sam was able to come back out first thing in the morning! Once again, he did an extremely thorough job, thinking through the project and coming up with a quick AND thoughtful fix that leaves our system in better shape than it was before the leak. Huge thank you to Sam and Gotelli for getting us back up and running so quickly! I wish I could give 0 stars.
Be forewarned!I called for a leaky pipe fix for my shampoo bowl in my salon. The leak was fixed well.
The problem was the man who fixed it also decided, without checking with me first, to change out my drain and stopper. I am not sure what he was thinking by doing this.
It cost me more for him to do this as well. I am a busy hair salon owner and decided that what was done was done and I thought that it would be ok and moved on.
I am short on time, he would have had to take it apart again and I am sure the old drain would not have been able to be put back in. My old drain and stopper were fine, it was a fairly new shampoo bowl.
It was not ok, it was a weird drain stop and I had to keep taking it out to let the water go down. I tried to find another drain stop, could not find one in my limited time.
Hair was building up in my drain. Several months quickly went by and I had to call them.
They refused to fix it saying I had a 30 day window and if I was unhappy, I should have called then. They admitted that a plumber should always get an ok when doing anything other than what was asked.
But they still said if I wanted anything done, I would be charged. Not cool.
Prompt, fast, efficient I called the office at 930am and Jared showed up sometime before noon. I'm still waiting to hear back from the other guys - The hardware on the shower was 50 years old and it started leaking last night, made me crazy to be wasting this water so getting someone here fast was a priority.
Ask for Jared, this guy was fast, knowledgeable, he had to do many workarounds with the generic store bought fixtures I provided to make everything fit, knew exactly what he was doing. By the way, Home Depot was a mess, a total sh-show in their bath fixture dept, every box of hardware was open so I wouldn't risk buying an incomplete kit, good ole Goodman's to the rescue.
Look, I had a great experience with these guys and would absolutely call them again. Go elsewhere.
Plumbers are nice enough but you better hope everything goes perfect. We had THREE visits to address what should have been a simple fix to a bathroom vanity.
Visit 1 caused a new leak, visit 2 didn't fix the leak (we paid both invoices) and visit 3 finally fixed the leak. We expected they would do the right thing and waive the visit 3 charges but no..
Threatening emails and calls from Laura and Danielle made us actually feel like the Italian Mob was after us and they went straight to threatening collections which is a huge turnoff. Then they indeed put us straight into collections and sent an email diatribe full of word salad as to why they're right and we're wrong.
Try to reply to the email...it gets bounced back by their mail system. Disgusting.
Classic study in how NOT to build lasting customer relationships with reasonable people. Should have looked at all the other negative reviews (with their combative responses) before selecting them.
#nevergotelli I called Gotelli after my sister-in-law informed me her kitchen sink had been back up for the past 3 days. She told me that a technician arrived the same day I had called.
Actually it was within an hour of me calling! She said the technician, Cory Nielsen, went above and beyond, was extremely polite, professional and helped guide her about her plumbing issues and any future work that should be done. She said she was extremely impressed and wouldn't hesitate to call them again! Same day appointments are almost unheard of in Marin but not only did the company return my call within the hour but offered two different time windows for that sane day.
Jeff was very knowledgeable and made suggestions to prevent a future plumbing crisis. While the pricing was high, the level of service received was well worth it--the "you get what you pay for" adage rings true in this case.
I will definitely call Gotelli again in the future based on my positive experience. Great service, ridiculously high prices!!! As you can see from some other recent reviews, Gotelli has changed their 'fee structure' and are now charging incredibly high prices for simple services.
For example, they snaked my kitchen sink line 18 months ago for $175. Not cheap, but in Marin County, it's probably a fair market price.
One week ago, same exact service, same sink, same problem...$460. How can you possibly explain a threefold price increase in 18 months time? And keep in mind, just to show up, they're going to charge you $89.
So you've got an acute issue you need help with, you're already $89 in, they figure you'll just agree to whatever they ask for, no matter how exorbitant it may be. To be fair, the plumbers are professional and honest and deserve credit for their work.
But the management is price gouging and seems just fine with it. I called the office and got the "you were aware of our new price policies, etc.
Thank you for sharing your concerns." Unless you're driving a Ferrari to work, I would strongly advise you to seek out other estimates because their prices are completely over the top unreasonable. After calling couple plumbing companies around town, we decided to have Gotelli replace our current tankless water heater, which broken after about 10 years.
Laura was the one who helped me, very nice lady. On the day of appt, Danny showed up on time, he has to relocate the WH due to the code has changed over the years and it has to be 4 ft away from windows and door, pain in the butt but he was able to do it.
Overall, a great experience dealing with Gotelli. We will continue to use them for any future plumbing needs I have never taken the time to write a review but I must take the time to write this one.
RIP OFF/DON'T USE....The rep came and within 5 min he said I needed a new hose for kitchen faucet which we were already aware of. He wrote out the estimate at it was going to be $590....for a 10 min job and the hose costs $90 (because my dad ended up purchasing the hose and put it in himself).
We also had to pay $89 which they were up front about and there was no issue there but when the rep said I'm not charging you the $89 I said oh is that deducted from the $590 and he said NO that is with the deduction. Totally feel taken advantage of as a consumer and lifetime resident of Marin.
I want you to know they gave us the estimate before working on the job but we while I initially said yes. I thought hmmmm seems very high and went back to my husband and told him the details, and at that point my husband declined the job.
The rep was annoyed and I can understand why. My father actually called day later to talk with owner who was just walking out the door, and could not take the time to talk so I decided to take the time and write this review.
Ive used other plumbers before and have never felt so ROBBED glad I was able to share my story with you all. In response to To your response!! Your response is laughable and insulting!! It's not about budget and not about affording the cost it's about ripping people off.
I have no complaint about your $89 cost and no complaint about your rep which you carried on about. You are not being honest about what the gal said she said you were walking out the door but who cares that's not the point it's about price gauging look at all your complaints!! Your a rip off!! Hear what you want to hear!! Take some accountability but your response is insulting and makes no sense when a hose cost $90 and installation takes 15 min do the math!! Unsubscribe!! Jared from Gotelli was great! Arrived on time.
Explained everything. He used all COVID-19 protocols.
He was not only polite and efficient but also took care not to disturb any of the garden while working. Will definitely use them for our next plumbing needs.
Jim and Terry I used to love Gotelli's and used them for 15 years. Unfortunately, their new pricing policy has sent me looking for a new plumber.
They now charge $89 to come out and perform an assessment. This is on top of the cost for any work you want done.
I know exactly what needs to be repaired (leaky faucet) but they still insist they need to do an assessment first (and charge the $89). I called several times and asked to speak with a manager (I've been a good customer for 15 years), but the manager refused to speak with me.
I'll miss their guys, but if they don't want my business, there are other plumbers in Marin. Just before October's "atmospheric river" hit, Jared of Gotelli Plumbing saved us from certain disaster.
We had had the downward-sloping driveway to our garage repaved, and the paving company (who shall remain unnamed here) had left the drain in front of the garage door totally blocked. Meanwhile, a member of the paver crew had shown up unannounced to "fix" the problem.
Diplomatically coordinating with the crewman, Jared, who had only come by to look at the situation and provide an estimate, was able, on the spot, to install new PVC, connect the drain and a secondary line from a French drain, and snake to make sure everything was clear. Hours later the storm hit.
Were it not for Jared's quick action, our garage surely would have flooded, as well as our home's lower level. A narrow escape, thanks to a great plumber! I had used them in the past to snake my clogged pipes and have been overall satisfied.
I'm disappointed in that they now require a $90 assessment charge to go through a quick checklist (took 5 minutes) to verify if there are other plumbing issues in the house. All this entailed was flushing toilets and running faucets to see if it drained properly.
I knew that when I called that I just needed them to snake my bathroom drain and that is what I should've been charged for. So it ended up being $185 to snake the drain plus $90 to "assess" other plumbing issues.
I thought Sam was a 4/5 in the service he provided, but the fact that they ripped me off knocks off all stars. I'll go somewhere else next time.
Tom from Gotelli is a quality guy and an excellent plumber. I have 100% confidence in his process and methodology for trouble shooting, sourcing the problem and coming up with at least two solutions (typically a lower cost fix and more expensive replacement/upgrade - which is fine.
he is expedient yet thorough. I would have Gotelli a five on this latest service were it not for the new higher pricing process.
My only hope is that it will save us money in the long run because they know our house and can get right to the issue without additional analysis. We will call them back and have used them in the past.
Kudos for Tom! Gotelli has be our "go to" plumbers for several years. Every year we need our front line cleaned because of a Chinese Elm with invasive roots.
Very simple procedure: we have a very accessible clean out valve in the front, it usually takes around 30 minutes, and has cost around $200. However, today the cost was quoted as almost $800 !!, with them saying that additional work needed to be done.
We have lived in our home for 35 years, this is a known problem, and we know the cost. From other reviews, it appears that Gotelli has changed their pricing policy, but no way should the same job close to four times as much as it did last year.
Obviously, this is our last call to this company. We called this company to change out two bathroom sink faucets.
They charged us $89 for just coming out to give us a ridiculous estimate of over $1400 for just the labor. We already had the new fixtures.
We ended up going with another plumber who was much friendlier and charged us only $330. I will never use Gotelli plumbing again as they seem only interested in getting their $89 service fee and then bid a crazy amount to actually do the work.
On a Thursday, I called 5 plumbers, left 4 messages and when I called Gotelli Plumbing, an actual human answered. They came out the next morning, replaced the plumbing under our kitchen sink.
The person who did the work was pleasant, did the job in a reasonable amount of time for a reasonable cost, and cleaned up after he was finished. I would definitely call them again! Grazie mille! Tom provided superb service above and beyond expected.
He cleaned up a plumbing nightmare under my kitchen sink left over from the days of galvanized. He was extremely helpful and explained the job as he went along.
Also, very respectful of the space. He kept his tools and parts organized and on a matted area off the tile.
The dispatch reception women, Rhonda and Lindsay, we're both extremely helpful and pleasant on the phone. From the easy going, friendly and professional attitude of their staff, it's clear that Gotelli takes care of their employees.
I prefer to do business with good people who treat people good. Awesome service company!! Go telli all your friends! Very professional, very accommodating and very successful unclogging solution to our plumbing emergency.
Many thanks! Gotelli plumbing really stepped up to the plate. I manage a business and we were dealing with a new installation that another company was unable to finish.
As soon as Gotelli was notified about the issue they quickly showed up and diagnosed the issue. Special shout out to Joe and Jake.
They were pro-active in there efforts in not only cleaning up the mess but making sure that they problem was thoroughly taken care. Thanks guys! These guys are great.
Very efficient and good quality work. They even took the time to answer questions about potential future work and give me high level estimates on amount of time so I can plan ahead.
Highly recommended! I just love this company! I had two toilets with problems and a leaky sink. I called and left a message with my problems and my address and then went to work, when I got home all problems were fixed! No fuss no mess.
They always just make it feel like magic for me. Thank you Laura Lee and your team for always getting the job done and done right.
Sam from Gotelli was terrific! We had problems due to someone else installing a new sink, dishwasher and shower fixtures. Sam from Gotelli Plumbing came in and saved the day.
He resolved all the issues quickly and efficiently. He was masked and professional.
I will keep Gotelli on speed dial. By the time the 'Other' plumbing company returned my calls (they are supposed to open at 7:00am & due to a meeting put my call on hold for 28 minutes, I found this out when they finally called me.), Sam was here installing a new pilot light unit for my hot water heater.
It was helpful to speak to Laura who could directly help me resolve the problem and tell me when someone could be at my house. The Other company called me 3x AFTER the job was done by Gotelli Plumbing, to set up an appointment tomorrow.
BEWARE. Gotelli, like a few other larger plumbing companies in the area, has moved to a system where they have set fees for certain jobs, and they are listed in a book.
These jobs are not billed on the actual hours it takes, yet on a set fee regardless. We recently had a gas leak, and were referred to them.
They came out, spent maybe 25 minutes charging our line to determine if there was a leak, then maybe another 15-20 minutes replacing a gas cock on our water heater. He was at our place for maybe 90 minutes...but we'll say 2 hours for the benefit of the doubt.
The fee? $1100!! Nearly $600/hour and all he did was determine that there was indeed a leak. Didn't fix anything.
Then told me he wouldn't be available to come back out to fix it for another 5 days. We ended up having someone else (reasonable) come out to replace the whole line.
He was at our place for a full day and a half (12+ hours) and charged us $2285 for labor AND all parts. I will NOT be using Gotelli again.
This practice leaves you feeling completely taken advantage of and vulnerable. Make sure you fully understand the charges before you move forward with this company.
(P.S. Tina, the dispatcher, was great.
Helpful, and understanding. Though she couldn't do anything about the company policy.
And the manager/owner was "unavailable" to speak to me. UPDATE 8/8/19: After sharing my displeasure with the way they charge flat fees for jobs regardless of the time spent, Tina contacted me today to let me know they were waiving the $89 "evaluation" fee, as well as reducing the charge for the gas cock.
While I still feel I was greatly overcharged for the time spent, I appreciate this gesture, and do feel "heard". RIPPED OFF!!! I've used Golelli's before so when it came to my H20 heater going out and a backed up drain in the master shower of course I called them first..
Who knew they'd screw a client over and loose a $5500 deal because of it!! $82.50 Cost them the deal!! Allow me to explain,..... Joey showed up took a look at my H20 heater and said no dice you need a new H20 heater cant fix it, no real detail as to why other than its full of water,.
He's the professional so I said ok, Tankless is the way to go he said,.. How much I asked.,.
he chuckled and responded "EXPENSIVE" very expensive but worth it, I'll have my boss call you,.. no other suggestion to a resolution was presented like the other plumbers.
So we moved on to the Shower,.... he turned the water on in both showers and sinks and in less than a couple of minutes said YUP,.
Its your sewer line,. we don't do sewer lines you'll need someone who specializes in Sewer lines and recommend Roy's Sewer Co..
I responded really?? There's no way to snake it?? NOPE,.. It's your sewer line, sorry!! Call Roy's,...
He went downstairs and came back up to let me know that since he couldn't do anything they'd give me a break on the cost of $165 and only charge me half since he was only here for 20minutes... He's the professional so I cut the check for $82.50 and said good bye and began looking up "Sewer Plumbers" after doing my research online I came across and write this down folks cause he was awesome and honest!! "SMART ROOTER & PLUMBING" Sam showed up at 5pm,.
first thing he did was pop the lid off the sewer line out front,. and said Mam,.
"YOUR SEWER LINE IS FINE" of course I responded No No Gotelli's assured me it was the sewer line and they couldn't fix it,.. He came inside ran the water as well and within 30-40 minutes snaked both showers BOOM problem solved.
When I told him Gotelli's charged me $82.50 and did nothing he shook his head and said they should refund me as it was fixable,.. I agreed.
So of course feeling taken advantage of by Gotelli's I asked him to look at my H20 heater as well,.. he agreed it was full of water and offered a few solutions including a Tankless at $5500.
I thanked him and said let me check the budget as I'd rather go Tankless than put a "shortie H20 heater in" HERES WERE IT GETS GOOD,.. The next day as Sam had said Gotelli's shouldn't have charged me since they actually could've fixed it and didn't and I paid $82.50 for nothing I called the office, a very nice lady was surprised that Joey told me they didn't do Sewer lines and she'd call me back,..
When she called back I had to laugh, she said " I s/w Joey and well generally speaking when the drains back up like that its the sewer line and I would've had to send 2 tech's out to fix it at $350. so actually you saved money by us only charging you for 1/2 the call, our base fee for showing up is $165 for an hour, I could charge you that instead if you like",....
HUH??? WHAT??? I responded that would be true if in fact it was the sewer line was backed up, but it wasn't. I would've rather paid the $165.
and he did the job as he should have" She repeated herself to say,. "well he thought it was the sewer line due to the back up" I responded that I paid for a professional to give me a professional assessment and had he taken the 2 minutes Smart Rooter & Plumbing did and looked at the sewer line he would've known that and completed the job, He never even tried to snake it" I would've rather paid the $165 for a completed job than $82.50 for nothing,..
Told her I do need a H20 heater and if you guys do the RIGHT thing I'd still consider them and chalk it up to a mistake on their part,.. I was told Sorry our policy is $165 and from our point of view we gave you a discount but we hope you will allow us to give you a quote" LMAO WHY??? So they can RIP ME OFF AGAIN?? NO Thank you!!! DID GOTELLI'S THINK THAT BECAUSE I'M A SINGLE MOTHER THEY COULD GET OVER ON ME??? NOT THIS SINGLE MOTHER!! I did get my Tankless installed by Sam & SMART ROOTER & PLMBING the other day and can I just say,..I love it and love them!! They were professional and hard working stayed late to get the job done and pointed out a few other plumbing things I may wish to consider replacing.
I trust them and am putting his recommendations on upgrades into my budget,.. THANK YOU SAM @ SMART ROOTER & PLUMBING!!!!! GOTELLI'S STEPPING OVER THOUSANDS TO PICK UP DOLLARS AND RIPPING OFF CUSTOMERS IN THE PROCESS!!! Similar to most of the recent reviews we too were shocked at Gotelli's new fee schedule.
We have used them on various projects for the past 20 years and have been very satisfied. However, we were given a quote of $3100 for work that ended up taking 4.5 hours.
Needless to say they just lost a long time customer. Highest praise for Gotelli on replacing our old on-demand water heater! Same day initial assessment, and replacement three days later.
Customer service was friendly and helpful. Could not be more pleased.
Good service = happy customers = repeat business! Gotelli Plumbing came to our rescue when we needed someone the same day for our clogged sink. I was amazed that we could get someone the same day.
Jeff was our plumber and he was the best plumber we've ever had. He was courteous, respectful, explained what he was doing and gave me some good advice for future.
He was a really nice person and was great with our dog. Jeff/Gotelli will be my go to plumber from now on.
I have used Gotelli Plumbing for almost twenty years and received good service and good workmanship. I am sorry that I did not check reviews before calling them the time.
We had them come out to fix a kitchen faucet that was leaking slightly. We had the parts ordered necessary to repair the faucet.
The end result was that the plumber took the faucet apart, could not put it back together. When he tried it was leaking all over and completely unusable.
We ended up with a bill of over $1100. The company would not do anything to correct this situation.
I will not use Gotelli Plumbing again. Beware!! I have been a loyal customer of Gotelli for years, spending thousand of dollars on repairs and major upgrades so it saddens me that I have to write this negative review.
Gotelli recently change their pricing policy from hourly to a cost per job. This is not unreasonable if the estimates are, at least, close to the actual work.
We had a clogged downspout drain. The technician came out and informed me that the this will take at least 4-5 hours and the cost will be $800.
After two hours the technician told me that the roots are too invasive and he will not be able to complete the repair, but was still going to need the full payment. This means I paid $400 per hour for job they could not complete.
I tried to call management to discuss and all they would say is that you agreed to pay this. I asked to have the owners call me to discuss, but after several days I have not received a response.
Apparently, they are making so much money off of their new pricing policy that they don't care about retaining loyal customers. It is clear (especially if you read other reviews on Yelp) that they are significantly overestimating the cost of jobs and have no problem ripping people off.
Time to find a new plumber. We have used this company in the past with great results, and the service techs are nothing less than professional.
However, this last call was very expensive for a family on a fixed income. Given that the job was similar in the past the cost to repairs where extremely high for work performed in less than two hours.
Reconsider using these guys only if money is no object. I called for a small job to fix our sink.
They had a technician 30 minutes after the call and fixed the problem immediately I love this company Prompt efficient clean I first called Gotelli Plumbing to install a water presser meter and they did a great job so when I decided to remodel my bathroom so I called them again. However this is what I have been left with - A bathtub that was not properly placed and continually needs caulking, and soon after installation the tub developed a small hairline crack, a toilet ring that leaked water into the garage that soon needed to be replaced, recommended expensive Grohe fixtures that have tarnished handles, scratched floor marble related to a pedestal sink that was installed, and now the piping under the pedestal sink is leaking water and staining the marble.
Responsibility denied for the bathtub fiacso and now I have another plumber cleaning up this mess. I chose Gotelli based on its reputation as a local family owned business and reviews.My experience was not a good one.
The plumber assigned was clearly not capable of handling the job, a small basement leak found by a contractor. The plumber identified the actual source of the problem after performing more than $500 of unrelated work.
At the end of the visit he reported that he had figured out the actual source of the leak. The next day, after calling in his manager and 2 extra workers, and spending the better part of a day, he accessed and replaced the leaky pipe.
I eventually recovered the first day's bill. I now have walls to repair and a hefty credit card bill.
Unfortunately, billable hours seems to trump honest, professional customer service . It is disheartening when a well regarded company falls off the rails.
I now know who not to call. I've never written a negative yelp review.
But I will now. I needed to reduce the temperature on my tankless water heater and have the tub re-caulked.
The guy came and left without fixing either. His behavior did, however, sufficiently bother my wife that after about 10 minutes she wanted me to ask him to leave.
I should trust her intuition more often. I called the office and spoke to a very nice person who conceded that this guy tends to rub people the wrong way and that this was not the first time a complaint had been made.
In the future, a different plumber would serve our account. Great, right? Problem solved? Nope.
I got a very unpleasant and very unnecessary call this morning from Gotelli. It was Laurel Lee who, I believe, is the president of the company, but I'm not sure if that's how to spell her name.
Regardless, without asking me a single question about my experience, she began to list reasons why the guy wouldn't do the caulk. She gave all sorts of excuses like, "the gap between the tub and the wall is too large" and "mold is a liability," and other attempts to complicate and redirect.
I couldn't help but start laughing when I responded. "Come on, Laurel Lee.
You weren't here. I'm telling you that this guy didn't give any of those reasons.
Don't give me all these other reasons now. That's not why he didn't do it.
He just didn't want to because he said "that's not what I do and I don't have almond colored caulk." I told him that I'd go to the hardware store 5 mins away and get it for him. That's when he flat out refused to do it and said we "should be using grout instead of caulk." "Well, mold is a serious issue." She said.
"Mold has nothing to do with it." I said. "He didn't say anything about mold!" She hung up on me.
It's clear to me that with this company, it's really hit or miss. As you can see from the reviews on Yelp, people are either very satisfied, or very unsatisfied with the work Gotelli performs and/or the way they are treated.
Honestly, based on my interaction with the receptionist, I would have given them another chance. But after my interaction with the president, no way.
Laurel Lee should learn from her receptionist that at least half of customer service is listening. The other half is solving the problem -- not defending and employee's poor performance with new excuses.
There are plenty of other plumbing companies in Marin. I'll use one of them for my next job and definitely would NOT recommend Gotelli Plumbing to a friend.
*UPDATE* My response to Laura Lee. The fact is that Tom did not solve the issues, at all.
This has nothing to do with how I feel. The temperature setting on the water heater is still malfunctioning and I ended up doing the caulking myself.
My complaint here is NOT that I should be refunded due to Tom's inability and unwillingness to resolve my issues. As I wrote in my original review, I would have given your company a second chance based on my interaction with your front desk staff.
My complaint is about YOU and your attempt me to "straighten me out." I'm a business owner too, and I would NEVER call a customer or vendor and treat them the way you treated me. It STILL infuriates me.
Your attitude, your tone of voice, your attempts to cloud the issue with irrelevant details, and your automatic defense of Tom's strange behavior are the reasons why I wrote this negative review. You were pissed off when you picked up the phone and dialed my number and dumped all that frustration on me.
And for what? Because there was a note on my file that we'd prefer a different member of your staff to serve our account? In the future, maybe you'll learn to treat your customers with some respect, listen to their issue, and come up with a solution according to their complaint. If you can't do that, leave the customer service to someone else on your team! Gotelli Plumbing is clean, talented and good to work with.
I called when the business opened for a valve problem in our kitchen. The well spoken in the office was very polite and said they had an opening between 1:00 and 3:00 that day and gave me the rate for the hour.
Tony showed up at the very beginning of that time frame. He was clean and welled dressed in his uniform.
No plumbers crack here! Tony brought in his own map to make sure there was no mess. Our business was conducted quickly and my problem was fixed! I have no idea why the one star reviews on these guys.
I would recommend them without worry. Thanks Gotelli Gotelli Plumbing does not stand by their work!! Had three bathroom faucets installed, months later one leaks into cabinet below.
I called main office and dispatcher told me they will not come out to fix the problem caused by them unless I pay another service call fee. What kind of SERVICE is that? They won't come back to correct a problem their technician caused in installing the faucet in the first place.
Do not hire Gotelli Plumbing, not a reputable company.'''.
Read less